Icon Phile — A Collector’s Guide to Sacred and Secular IconsCollecting icons—whether sacred devotional panels or secular works inspired by the language of iconography—is a pursuit that blends aesthetic appreciation, historical curiosity, and spiritual resonance. This guide is for collectors at every level: newcomers seeking a solid foundation, intermediate collectors building a focused assemblage, and seasoned connoisseurs refining attribution and care. It covers history and styles, how to authenticate and value icons, ethical and legal considerations, display and conservation, and building a meaningful collection that resonates visually and intellectually.
What is an icon?
An icon is a painted (or sometimes mosaic, relief, or printed) image, traditionally serving as a focal point for devotion in the Eastern Christian, particularly Orthodox, traditions. Icons represent saints, Christ, the Virgin Mary (Theotokos), biblical scenes, and feasts. Over centuries the term has broadened: many secular artists have adopted iconographic styles, producing works that reference or reinterpret the visual language of icons for non-religious themes.
Key fact: An icon is both an object of veneration and a cultural artifact.
A brief history and major traditions
Icons emerged in late antiquity and matured in the Byzantine Empire. Key historical phases:
- Early Christian (3rd–6th centuries): development of symbolic language; survivals are rare.
- Byzantine classical (6th–9th centuries): stylistic consolidation; large-scale church mosaics and portable panels.
- Iconoclastic period (726–843): destruction and debates about images; post-Iconoclasm produced a flowering of icon painting.
- Medieval and post-Byzantine (9th–15th centuries and beyond): regional schools—Greek, Russian, Balkan, Cretan—diverge in style and technique.
- Russian tradition (11th century onward): particularly known for panel icons, ikons’ refinement, and later secular adaptations.
- Modern and contemporary: artists use iconographic conventions for secular, political, or personal expression.
Styles, materials, and techniques
Recognizing a region or period helps attribution and valuation.
- Tempera on wood panels: egg tempera applied to gessoed wood is the classic technique.
- Gold leaf backgrounds: a signature of Byzantine and many later icons; genuine gold leaf has specific visual qualities.
- Iconography tools: bole (red clay) underlayer, gesso (animal glue and chalk), egg tempera, gold leaf, and varnish (sometimes later).
- Iconographic conventions: frontal poses, hierarchical scaling (important figures larger), inverse perspective, and stylized anatomy meant to convey spiritual truth rather than naturalism.
- Secular variants: mixed media, different supports (canvas, paper), and modern pigments.
Authentication and attribution
Proper authentication combines visual connoisseurship, technical analysis, provenance, and documentary evidence.
- Visual clues: stylistic coherence with a school or master; brushwork, palette, and composition.
- Technical testing: dendrochronology for wooden panels; pigment analysis (XRF, Raman) to date materials; IR/UV imaging to reveal underdrawing or restorations.
- Provenance: auction records, dealer documentation, ecclesiastical records, or archival photos strengthen attribution and value.
- Red flags: anachronistic pigments (e.g., modern synthetic pigments in purportedly 17th-century icons), poor repairs that alter original surfaces, and vague or missing provenance.
Tip: For high-value icons, insist on a technical report and provenance documentation before purchase.
Valuation factors
Price depends on age, condition, rarity, provenance, artist or school, and market trends.
- Age: older, well-dated works (e.g., Byzantine, early Russian) are often more valuable.
- Condition: original paint layers, minimal overpainting, and intact gilding increase value; sympathetic conservation preferred.
- Rarity and subject: uncommon saints or large-scale panels can command premiums.
- Artist/school: identified works by known masters or major workshops are prized.
- Market dynamics: demand, exhibition histories, and scholarly attention affect prices.
Ethical and legal considerations
Collecting religious and cultural artifacts carries responsibilities.
- Export and import laws: many countries restrict export of cultural heritage; seek proper export licenses and documentation.
- Deaccessioning and restitution: be cautious with items potentially subject to repatriation claims.
- Sacred context: icons from active liturgical contexts may have been removed; consider the ethical implications and community ties.
- Due diligence: verify legal title and ensure no illicit excavation or trafficking history.
Buying channels and tips
- Reputable dealers and galleries: offer authentication support and return policies.
- Auctions: can yield bargains but require careful pre-bid research and condition checks.
- Estate sales and monasteries: sometimes source authentic pieces; monasteries occasionally sell duplicates or redundant icons.
- Fairs and shows: opportunity to compare pieces and meet specialists.
- Online marketplaces: convenient but riskier—ask for high-resolution images, condition reports, and provenance.
Checklist before buying:
- High-resolution photos (front, back, edges, close-ups of paint and gilding)
- Provenance documents
- Technical analysis (for valuable pieces)
- Return policy and authenticity guarantee
- Clear export/import documentation
Caring for icons: conservation basics
Proper environmental control and handling extend an icon’s life.
- Environment: steady temperature (ideally 15–22°C / 59–72°F) and relative humidity 45–55%. Avoid abrupt changes.
- Light: keep light levels low—avoid direct sunlight; use UV-filtered lighting.
- Handling: always support panels by edges; wear nitrile gloves to prevent oil transfer.
- Framing and backing: use archival materials; allow for wood movement with spacers and avoid sealing paintings airtight.
- Restoration: consult a conservator experienced with tempera and gilding. Avoid amateur retouching.
Displaying icons
Display choices should respect both aesthetic and cultural dimensions.
- Orientation: traditionally hung at eye level for devotional engagement; many collectors group icons by school, subject, or palette.
- Lighting: soft, directional lighting emphasizes surface and gilding; avoid heat-producing lamps.
- Contextual labels: include short date/school/provenance notes for viewers.
- Security: secure mounting and climate-stable cases for valuable pieces.
Building a coherent collection
Define goals: historical depth, regional focus, thematic (e.g., Theotokos), or contemporary reinterpretations.
- Start small: focus on reliable attributions and condition.
- Educate: study catalogues raisonnés, museum collections, and scholarly literature.
- Network: join collector societies, attend conferences, and consult curators.
- Document: keep meticulous records—acquisition receipts, condition reports, photographs, and conservation history.
Collecting secular icons and contemporary reinterpretations
Contemporary artists often adopt iconographic language to explore identity, politics, and aesthetics.
- Value considerations: contemporary works may appreciate differently; exhibition history and critical recognition matter.
- Display: juxtaposing sacred and secular icons highlights formal continuities and conceptual differences.
- Ethical notes: be clear in labeling to avoid confusion with authentic liturgical objects.
Resources and further reading
- Museum collections with strong icon holdings (catalogs are invaluable).
- Conservation literature on tempera, gilding, and panel supports.
- Auction house archives and specialist dealers’ catalogs.
- Scholarly journals in Byzantine and Russian art history.
Final advice
Collecting icons rewards patience, research, and ethical care. Focus on learning technical markers and provenance standards, work with trusted specialists, and prioritize preservation. Over time, a thoughtful collection will not only appreciate but also tell a layered story of faith, artistry, and cultural exchange.
Leave a Reply